Learning tasks: Presentation of three opinions proposing a view on the issue concerning vegetarianism as a solution to climate change, and comments on pros & cons
Tools/resources:
Comments on Proposed Views
|
|||
|
Learning tasks: Presentation of three opinions proposing a view on the issue concerning vegetarianism as a solution to climate change, and comments on pros & cons Tools/resources: • 31 May 2008 Earth Walk (Scoop Independent News, New Zealand)
• Article by Meat-the-Facts.org from Al Gore’s campaign (Nov. 2009)
• Video of the 2010 SOS Campaign, by SupremeMasterTV (YouTube)
Comments on Proposed Views o Campaigns aim at providing alternative ways to look at things
o Public events can be very catchy, conceived for wide distribution
o Result quite convincing despite few, vague, partially concrete data
o Scientific evidence is not there, but data on consumption confirm (corporations’ role, non-respected precautionary principles, waste, feeding, pharmaceuticals, etc.)
o Cruel slaughter practices get mixed with environmental issues – moral and scientific approaches are entangled
o But: theory slightly sounding new-age or too philosophical
o Important sense of promoting individual responsibility/commitment
Learning tasks: Presentation of related interviews and articles, and comments on the proposed/diverging opinions Tools/resources: Web-based information sources including blogs, social networks, scientific magazines, media, etc. Related articles and interviews
The Meatrix – Cool interactive tool!!!!
(Source: UNEP) Reflecting on the opinons: o More info available: less secret, less sectoral, more divulgative
o Health studies reveal and promote the advantages of being veg
o Environmental studies too! Farming is polluting, does not generate distributed income, creates waste difficult to manage, produces unhappy animals that end up in our stomachs!
o Relationships with climate change-related issues gets strengthened
o Markets may find both advantages and disadvantages in the trend
o The dynamic of the consensus induces not questioning
o The habit is spreading: no more “fashionable” but “conscience” issue
o Scientific data influence people’s habits
o But: vegetarianism alone is not sufficient
o There is no one single all-valid solution to climate change!
Learning tasks: Web-based general information about climate change and its discussed solutions Tools/resources: o Web versions of scientific media, specialized blogs, thematic books
o IPCC, UNFCCC, IUCN, FAO, UNEP papers and reports
SOLUTIONS ? ?
Useful Information o The debate over the matter is heated
o The implications of market-related dynamics are treacherous
o Science, market and politics cannot be working at the same pace
o Information sharing/access is crucial
o Civil society action is essential
o Individual empowerment is a substantive tool
Boycotting makes sense!! Learning tasks: Vegetarianism & around Tools/resources: Web-based information on the matter by science & health sources, lifestyle media, social networks/clubs/associations, commercials, books, etc.
Jonathan Safran Foer‘s book “Eating animals”
Wrap up – Expression of Personal View / Opinion o I am a vegetarian since teenage, for health reasons
o I strongly believe that “every single drop contributes”
o Personal commitment is what empowers each of us
o We can’t afford to wait till the scientific evidence is provided
o We can’t depend on top-down guidance to undertake decisions
o We can’t: not wonder, not question, not care, not take action
“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world (Margaret Mead)
“We ourselves feel that what we are doing is just a drop in the ocean. But the ocean would be less because of that missing drop” (Mother Teresa)
“What you can do is just a drop in the ocean, but it is what gives meaning to your life” (Albert Schweitzer, Peace Nobel Prize 1953 speech)
Topic: Addressing global environmental issues as an active Citizen Title: Be Veg, Go Green, Save the Planet – Is being a vegetarian a way to address global environmental issues? Short description: Serious world-wide environmental concerns call increasingly for our individual attention and engagement towards finding sustainable solutions and viable alternatives to consumption patterns. Being vegetarian is now proposed as a sound way: is this so? Could it at least be considered – beyond moral and ideological meaning – an individual commitment to the goal? Do we have any means to measure how effective it is? Be Veg, Go Green, Save the Planet – Campaign Ad
List of activities Activity 1: Presentation of three campaigning tools promoting a view on the issue concerning vegetarianism as a solution to climate change, and comments on pros & cons Activity 2: Related interviews and articles, and comments on the proposed/diverging opinions Activity 3: Web-based general information about climate change and some of its discussed solutions, influenced by political implications Activity 4: Vegetarianism & around Wrap up – Expression of Personal View / Opinion
“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world (Margaret Mead)
“We ourselves feel that what we are doing is just a drop in the ocean. But the ocean would be less because of that missing drop” (Mother Teresa)
Peace Nobel Prize 1953 speech: “What you can do is just a drop in the ocean, but it is what gives meaning to your life” (Albert Schweitzer)
|
|||
|
2013 Posts Feed |
|||